Why did they stop teaching phonics? Dr. Barker Says

Rocky the reading dog

Quick & Easy Less Than 10 Min Assessment To Find Where Your Child May Be Falling Behind

Fill out the form and we’ll send you a free assessment to help you identify your child’s strengths and possible areas for growth.

Knowledge Today A Brighter Tomorrow

Dr. Barker Why did they stop teaching phonicsDr. Barker Why did they stop teaching phonics, child studying

Why did they stop teaching phonics? Many schools did not drop phonics entirely, but for years they shifted toward whole language and later balanced literacy approaches, which often taught phonics less directly and encouraged children to use pictures and context to figure out words. Interest in systematic phonics has grown again in recent years, and many schools are bringing it back.

For parents of 1st and 2nd graders, the practical question is not history but what your child’s school does now. Ask how phonics is taught, how often, and how the school checks that each child is learning the sound patterns.

Dr. Barker says about Why did they stop teaching phonics?

These lines come from Dr. Nancy Barker’s 2011 Pepperdine dissertation, Systems change: A study of response to intervention model implementation. Her study looked at how two Southern California elementary schools put Response to Intervention into practice. Read Like Rocky uses the same idea behind her research.

Why did they stop teaching phonics? Dr. Barker says, “However, as each student is different, so is the structure of the organization in which they learn.” (Barker, 2011, p. 1). Schools adopt different reading approaches, and the way a school is organized shapes what reaches each child.

Why did they stop teaching phonics? A California Department of Education principle cited in Dr. Barker’s dissertation reads, “All children can learn when provided an effective instructional environment.” (CDE, as cited in Barker, 2011, p. 4). A child who has not been taught phonics clearly may simply not have had that environment yet.

Why did they stop teaching phonics? Dr. Barker says, “…educators need to ensure that all students are provided with an opportunity to learn.” (Barker, 2011, p. 10). Clear phonics teaching is one way schools make sure every child has a fair chance to learn to read.

When did they stop teaching phonics, and what replaced it?

  • Whole language approaches, popular in many schools in the 1980s and 1990s, focused on reading real books and meaning, with phonics taught less systematically.
  • Balanced literacy blended some phonics with leveled books and strategies such as looking at the picture or the first letter to guess a word.
  • The return of phonics: research reviews and parent and teacher advocacy have pushed many schools toward explicit, systematic phonics again.

Why did they stop teaching phonics in some classrooms? Common reasons given

  • A belief that children learn to read naturally from lots of exposure to books.
  • Concern that phonics drills were boring.
  • Programs that taught guessing strategies alongside or instead of sounding out.

Today, many educators agree that most children benefit from being taught letter-sound patterns directly and in order.

What it can look like if your child missed clear phonics

  • Guessing words from pictures or first letters.
  • Strong memory for familiar books but trouble with new text.
  • Difficulty spelling words the way they sound.

What to try at home

Ask what the school uses

Ask the name of the phonics program and what pattern your child is learning this week.

Practice sounding out

Point to each letter, say the sounds, and blend. Praise the effort of sounding out over a quick guess.

Use decodable text

Books built from the patterns your child has learned let them practice phonics in real sentences.

When to talk with the teacher

If your child is guessing more than sounding out, or seems to have missed basic patterns, ask the teacher how they check phonics skills and whether extra practice or intervention is available.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did they stop teaching phonics?
There was no single date. Many schools moved away from systematic phonics during the whole language and balanced literacy years, roughly the 1980s onward, and practice varied by district.

Do schools still teach phonics?
Many do, and more schools are adding explicit, systematic phonics. Ask your child’s school how it is taught.

Why is phonics instruction alone not sufficient?
Phonics is essential, but children also need vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension to understand what they read.

What is the three-cueing method?
It asks children to use meaning, sentence structure, and letters to figure out words. Critics say it can encourage guessing instead of sounding out.

Can I teach phonics at home if the school does not?
Yes. Short daily practice with letter sounds, blending, and decodable books can help a lot.

What's Included in the 12-Week Program? step-by-step reading lessons; your child's personalized learning path; practice activities and progress checks; parent teaching guides; learn with Rocky or learn together; a 12-week progress reassessment and report; and parent support included.

What’s Included in the 12-Week Program?

Everything you need to build stronger reading skills, confidence, and a lifelong love of learning.

  • Step-by-Step Reading Lessons Structured lessons matched to the reading skills your child needs to strengthen.
  • Your Child’s Personalized Learning Path The assessment identifies where to begin, so your child works on the right skills — not simply material based on age or grade.
  • Practice Activities & Progress Checks Fun, engaging activities reinforce each skill, with regular checks to see what’s improving and what still needs practice.
  • Parent Teaching Guides Simple, step-by-step instructions show you exactly how to help — without needing teaching experience.
  • Learn With Rocky or Learn Together Children who are ready can work more independently with Rocky, while parents who want to participate can follow Nancy’s guided approach.
  • 12-Week Progress Reassessment & Report At the end of the program, your child completes a fresh assessment showing strengths, observed progress, remaining needs, and the recommended next learning step.
  • Parent Support Included Join Motivation Mondays, Help Wednesdays, Friday Q&A with Nancy Barker. You don’t have to do this alone! You Have a WHOLE TEAM!
Rocky the reading dog

Quick & Easy Less Than 10 Min Assessment To Find Where Your Child May Be Falling Behind

Fill out the form and we’ll send you a free assessment to help you identify your child’s strengths and possible areas for growth.

Knowledge Today A Brighter Tomorrow

Related questions

This question is part of 1st–2nd Grade Reading in Questions Parents Ask.

Find out where your child should start

Read Like Rocky was created by Dr. Nancy Barker, Ed.D., who has 49 years in education. The where-to-start page walks you through a free first step, so you can see which reading skills look solid and which ones to practice next. Adaptive Rocky lessons are coming.

Find where your child should start

About the author: Dr. Nancy Barker, Ed.D. (Pepperdine), 49 years in education, creator of Read Like Rocky.

Research: Barker, N. (2011). Systems change: A study of response to intervention model implementation [Doctoral dissertation, Pepperdine University]. https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/etd/173/.

This page is educational and is not a medical or school evaluation.

Rocky the reading dog

Quick & Easy Less Than 10 Min Assessment To Find Where Your Child May Be Falling Behind

Fill out the form and we’ll send you a free assessment to help you identify your child’s strengths and possible areas for growth.

Knowledge Today A Brighter Tomorrow